When you upgrade from a headset mic, the first big choice is the connector: USB or XLR. It sounds like a technical detail, but it decides what else you need to buy, how easy setup is, and how far you can upgrade later.
Forge PC has not tested the microphones or interfaces mentioned here. This comparison is based on Shure's guidance on USB microphones and streaming audio, and product details from Shure and Focusrite, checked on 15 November 2026.
The key difference
A USB microphone has the electronics that turn your voice into digital audio built in. Shure explains that a converter inside the mic turns the analogue signal into digital data before it reaches your PC, which is why you normally don't need extra drivers.
An XLR microphone sends an analogue signal down a three-pin XLR cable. To use it with a PC, you need an audio interface (or a mixer) to boost the signal with a preamp and convert it to digital. A one-input interface such as Focusrite's Scarlett Solo is a typical starting point; Focusrite describes it as having a mic preamp, an instrument input for guitar, a headphone output and Loopback for capturing audio from other apps.
| USB microphone | XLR microphone + interface |
|---|
What you need | Mic and a USB cable | Mic, XLR cable, audio interface |
Setup | Plug in and select it in Windows | More parts, more settings |
Upgrading | Replace the whole mic | Swap the mic or the interface separately |
More than one mic | Awkward | Easy with a multi-input interface |
Hardware controls | On the mic or in its app | Mostly on the interface |
Is XLR better quality?
Not automatically. Shure argues that USB microphones have come a long way and now combine convenience with "tremendous sound quality". What XLR gives you is flexibility. Shure's own advice is that if you want a distinctive sound, an analogue XLR mic with an interface makes more sense, because a USB mic has its converter built in and is designed as an all-rounder.
In other words, a good USB mic will beat a cheap XLR mic, and the room you record in matters more than the connector.
Dynamic or condenser matters as much
Shure's advice for streaming from home is that a dynamic microphone is usually the better choice. Dynamics are generally less sensitive to everything happening around you, so they pick up less keyboard noise, room echo and sound from other rooms. Condenser mics can sound great in treated studios but pick up more of a typical bedroom.
The type also affects what you need: Shure explains that phantom power (a DC voltage of 11 to 48 volts) powers the preamp of a condenser microphone and is normally supplied by the mixer or interface. Check that your interface provides it if you choose an XLR condenser.
The middle ground: mics with both
Some microphones now have both connectors. Shure's MV7+, for example, has USB-C and XLR outputs, so you can start by plugging it straight into your PC and add an interface later. Over USB, Shure's MOTIV Mix app adds features such as Voice Isolation, an Auto Level Mode that adjusts gain, and a real-time Denoiser. If you prefer a USB-only mic, our database includes options such as the Elgato Wave:3 and Shure MV6 Gen 2.
Which should you choose?
Choose USB if: - you want one cable and no extra boxes on the desk - you stream or chat alone from a normal room - you want software features such as automatic levels and noise reduction
Choose XLR if: - you want to swap or upgrade mics without replacing everything - you need more than one microphone, for example for a co-host - you already own, or plan to buy, an audio interface
Choose a hybrid USB and XLR mic if you want to start simple but keep the upgrade path open.
For specific recommendations, see our best microphones for streaming, and for the software side, our guide to setting up a PC for streaming and the NVIDIA Broadcast vs AMD noise suppression comparison.
Our verdict
For most gamers and solo streamers, a dynamic USB microphone is the simplest route to clear audio: one cable, no interface and useful software processing. XLR is the better long-term system if you want to upgrade parts separately or add more mics, but it costs more to get started and needs an interface with phantom power if you choose a condenser. Hybrid mics with both outputs are the safest bet if you're unsure. Forge PC has not tested these microphones; guidance is from Shure and Focusrite.