Skip to content

VersusGPU

ComfyUI vs InvokeAI: Which Local AI Image Generator Should You Use?

ComfyUI is the more flexible local AI image generator: a node graph, offline-first core and broad GPU support, including Radeon on Windows via its desktop app. Invoke suits artists, with a layered canvas, inpainting, a gallery and optional node workflows, but it supports AMD GPUs only on Linux. Both are free and open source.

By , Editorial team

3 min read

ComfyUI vs InvokeAI: Which Local AI Image Generator Should You Use?

If you want to generate AI images on your own graphics card rather than in the cloud, two names come up again and again: ComfyUI and Invoke, whose GitHub repository is still called InvokeAI. Both are free and open source, both run models such as SDXL and FLUX locally, and both have node-based workflows. They're aimed at quite different ways of working, though.

This comparison is based on each project's official documentation and GitHub pages. Forge PC hasn't benchmarked the two apps against each other, so we make no claims about which generates images faster.

The short answer

  • Choose ComfyUI if you want maximum control, the newest models and video or audio workflows. It also suits you if you're happy wiring nodes together or loading workflows other people have shared.

  • Choose Invoke if you think like an artist: you want a canvas with layers, inpainting and brush tools, a tidy gallery, and node workflows only when you need them.

At a glance

ComfyUI

Invoke

Main interface

Node graph

Canvas with layers, plus a workflow editor

Licence

GPL-3.0

Apache-2.0 (the repository also includes some model licences)

Install

Desktop app or portable install

Official Invoke Launcher

GPU support (per docs)

NVIDIA, AMD, Intel, Apple Silicon and Ascend via the desktop app

NVIDIA; AMD on Linux only; Intel Arc on Windows and Linux; Apple Silicon

Offline use

Core runs fully offline unless you request a download

Local generation; optional API-backed external models

ComfyUI: the node graph

ComfyUI describes itself as a modular diffusion model GUI, API and backend with a graph/nodes interface. You build a pipeline from nodes (load model, prompt, sampler, decode, save) and can reuse it as a workflow. Its GitHub page highlights:

  • workflows for images, video, 3D, audio and text

  • reusable subgraphs, workflow templates, an App Mode and a local API

  • smart VRAM and RAM management, model offloading and support for quantised models

  • fully offline operation: the core doesn't download anything unless you request it, and an --offline flag forces built-in features to stay offline

  • a huge library of custom nodes

The trade-off is the learning curve. A blank node graph can be intimidating, though shared workflows and templates help. Start with our guide to installing ComfyUI on Windows, then try LoRAs and ControlNet.

Invoke: the canvas

Invoke's GitHub page puts its Unified Canvas front and centre: a canvas with all the core generation tools, in-painting and out-painting, brushes and more, designed so artists can use AI as a creative collaborator. Its documentation also covers vector layers, shapes, lasso and text tools, and a gallery with boards. Images keep their metadata, so you can recall the prompt and settings later.

Invoke isn't only a canvas. It has a node-based workflow editor and a custom node manager, and its documentation includes a ComfyUI migration guide. Installation goes through the official Invoke Launcher, which installs Python for you and handles updates.

Hardware: check before you choose

Invoke publishes a hardware table by model. As a rough guide, it lists FLUX.1 at 1024x1024 as needing an NVIDIA RTX 20-series or newer card with 10GB of VRAM and 32GB of system RAM. Invoke says cards with less VRAM usually still work, just more slowly. On AMD, Invoke supports Radeon GPUs on Linux only. Intel Arc (Alchemist, Battlemage and newer) is supported on Windows and Linux.

ComfyUI's desktop app supports NVIDIA, AMD, Intel, Apple Silicon and Ascend hardware, according to its GitHub page. That makes it the more flexible choice if you're running a Radeon card on Windows. For low-VRAM cards, see running ComfyUI on low VRAM and how much VRAM you need.

Other options

If neither appeals, our guides compare ComfyUI with Forge WebUI and ComfyUI with Amuse, and our best local AI image generators round-up covers the wider field.

Our verdict

ComfyUI is the more powerful and flexible tool. Its node graph, offline-first design and broad GPU support (including Radeon on Windows via the desktop app) make it the pick for tinkerers and anyone chasing the newest models. Invoke is the friendlier choice for artists, with a layered canvas, inpainting tools, a gallery and node workflows when you need them. Check Invoke's hardware table first, though, as it supports AMD cards only on Linux. Both are free, so it's worth trying each with the same model.

The bottom line

ComfyUI is the more powerful and flexible tool. Its node graph, offline-first design and broad GPU support (including Radeon on Windows via the desktop app) make it the pick for tinkerers and anyone chasing the newest models. Invoke is the friendlier choice for artists, with a layered canvas, inpainting tools, a gallery and node workflows when you need them. Check Invoke's hardware table first, though, as it supports AMD cards only on Linux. Both are free, so it's worth trying each with the same model.

Sources

  1. 01ComfyUI (Comfy-Org) on GitHub
  2. 02Invoke (invoke-ai/InvokeAI) on GitHub
  3. 03Invoke documentation, Hardware Requirements
  4. 04Invoke documentation, Simple Installation

About the author

Forge PC Staff

Editorial team

The shared byline for articles researched, written and edited by the Forge PC editorial team. How we source, check and correct our work is set out in our editorial policy.

More from Forge PC Staff

Read next

HDR10 vs HDR10+ vs Dolby Vision on PC: What Your Monitor's HDR Badge Means

Versus

HDR10 vs HDR10+ vs Dolby Vision on PC: What Your Monitor's HDR Badge Means

HDR10 uses static metadata and is the format Windows HDR is built around. HDR10+ adds royalty-free dynamic metadata, and HDR10+ Gaming certifies both monitor and GPU. Windows picks Dolby Vision automatically on certified monitors, but Microsoft warns some cap brightness in that mode. Panel brightness and contrast matter more than the badge.

Forge PC Staff3 min

How to Fix Games Crashing on PC: A Step-by-Step Checklist for Windows 11

How-To

How to Fix Games Crashing on PC: A Step-by-Step Checklist for Windows 11

Most PC game crashes come from drivers, corrupted files or unstable overclocks. Update, roll back or clean-install the graphics driver, verify the game's files, run DISM and SFC, and reset GPU and memory tuning to stock. If crashes continue, check temperatures, test RAM with MemTest86 and look at the power supply.

Forge PC Staff3 min

KoboldCpp vs LM Studio: Which Local AI App Should You Use?

Versus

KoboldCpp vs LM Studio: Which Local AI App Should You Use?

KoboldCpp is a single, install-free executable built on llama.cpp, with CUDA and Vulkan builds plus image, speech and agent features and a story-writing UI. LM Studio is a polished app that finds and downloads models for you and serves them over an OpenAI-like API. LM Studio suits most people; KoboldCpp suits tinkerers and writers.

Forge PC Staff3 min

How to Use Radeon Chill: Cut Power, Heat and Fan Noise on AMD Graphics Cards

How-To

How to Use Radeon Chill: Cut Power, Heat and Fan Noise on AMD Graphics Cards

Radeon Chill lowers your frame rate when there's little movement in a game and ramps it up when the action starts, saving power and heat. Turn it on in AMD Software's Global Graphics, set Min and Max FPS, override per game and toggle it with Alt+F11. It disables Anti-Lag and Boost and doesn't work with UWP games.

Forge PC Staff3 min