Look at any mechanical keyboard listing and you'll see the keycaps described as ABS or PBT. They're the two most common keycap plastics, and they feel and age differently. The short answer is that PBT usually lasts better, but the way the letters (legends) are made matters just as much, and a good ABS set can beat a poor PBT one.
This comparison draws on keycap guidance from HyperX, Wooting and Kinetic Labs. Forge PC hasn't tested specific keycap sets, so there are no wear tests here.
Quick comparison
| ABS | PBT |
|---|
Surface over time | Becomes shiny and slick with use | Much more resistant to shine |
Feel | Smooth | Textured, matte |
Sound | HyperX: can sound "softer"; Wooting: higher-pitched | Deeper, often described as "crisp" |
RGB shine-through | Bright | Doesn't shine through as easily |
Colours | Easier to make vivid colours | Harder to get bright colours |
Manufacturing | Easier, more consistent | Harder to control |
Price | Usually cheaper | Generally more expensive |
ABS: cheaper, brighter and better for RGB, but it shines
ABS (acrylonitrile butadiene styrene) is the most common keycap material, according to HyperX. It's easier to mould consistently, it takes vivid colours well, and it lets keyboard lighting shine through brightly, which is why so many RGB keyboards use it.
The downside is wear. HyperX says ABS surfaces become shiny, slick and reflective over time, printed legends may fade, and keycaps can be brittle where they attach to the switch. Kinetic Labs adds that ABS yellows faster than PBT under UV light, which is why many old beige keyboards look tinted.
Quality varies, though. Wooting points out that GMK, a well-known premium keycap maker, uses only ABS, and its sets are expensive and in high demand.
PBT: tougher and less shiny, with a duller look
PBT (polybutylene terephthalate) is harder and more wear-resistant, according to HyperX. Even if its textured surface smooths a little over time, it won't shine nearly as quickly as ABS. It's also resistant to solvents and chemicals. PBT keycaps are typically thicker, which gives a deeper, crisper sound that some people love and others find loud.
The trade-offs are a duller look, less vivid colours, weaker light shine-through and a higher price. Wooting adds two useful caveats: PBT keycaps are rarely 100% PBT (it's often mixed with other materials), and a manufacturer can make poor PBT keycaps just as it can make great ABS ones. Kinetic Labs notes that some PBT sets use ABS for the largest keys, such as the space bar, because ABS shrinks less during moulding.
The legends matter as much as the plastic
How the letters are made often decides how long a keyboard looks new:
Double-shot: the legend and keycap are moulded from two separate shots of plastic. Wooting says this always gives the longest-lasting legends and is used with both ABS and PBT. If the legend plastic is translucent, it works with backlighting.
Dye-sublimation: the legend is dyed into the plastic using heat. Wooting says this is used on PBT because ABS can't withstand the heat. It doesn't support backlighting.
Painted and laser-etched: common on ABS backlit keyboards. HyperX says printed or etched legends on ABS can fade over time.
So "double-shot PBT" is the safest choice for long-lasting keycaps with RGB, while "dye-sub PBT" suits non-backlit boards.
Which should you choose?
Choose PBT if: you type a lot, hate shiny keys, or want a deeper sound. Double-shot PBT keeps legends readable and works with lighting.
Choose ABS if: you want the brightest RGB, vivid colours or a smoother feel, or you're on a budget. Double-shot ABS still avoids worn-off legends.
Keycaps can be replaced later on many mechanical keyboards, so the switches and build often matter more when you buy. See our best gaming keyboards, linear vs tactile vs clicky switches and hot-swappable vs soldered keyboards.
Our verdict
PBT keycaps are usually the better long-term choice: they're harder, resist shine and have a textured, matte feel, though they cost more and don't show off RGB as well. ABS is cheaper, more colourful and better for lighting, but it gets shiny with use. Check the legend type too: double-shot legends last longest on either plastic, and a well-made ABS set can still beat cheap PBT.