A proposed class action accusing the world's three biggest memory makers of colluding to restrict supply of ordinary DRAM has cleared its first major hurdle. On 14 November 2026, US District Judge Noël Wise of the Northern District of California denied a motion by Samsung, SK hynix and Micron to dismiss the case.
The ruling is not a finding that anyone broke the law. At this stage a court only decides whether the claims are plausible enough to proceed, treating the plaintiffs' well-pleaded allegations as true. Forge PC hasn't seen any evidence beyond the court's order and published reporting; everything below describes allegations, not proven facts.
What the case alleges
The case is Garciaguirre et al v. Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. et al (case 5:26-cv-06345). According to the judge's order, the named plaintiffs are 17 consumers and small businesses from five US states, and the complaint was filed on 25 June 2026. It claims that since October 2022 the three companies have maintained a conspiracy to restrain trade in conventional DRAM (the DDR4 and DDR5 memory used in PCs, LPDDR in phones and server memory), in breach of the Sherman Act.
The order summarises four alleged courses of "parallel conduct":
Simultaneous production cuts between October 2022 and April 2023, during the memory "winter".
A coordinated pivot to HBM, the high-bandwidth memory used in AI accelerators, from March 2023.
A coordinated exit from DDR3 and DDR4 during 2024 and 2025.
Refusing to expand conventional DRAM supply after the third quarter of 2025, even as prices soared.
The plaintiffs also point to Samsung and SK hynix reportedly refusing long-term contracts with major conventional DRAM customers while signing long-term HBM deals, delays to pre-announced new fabs, "customer vetting" of DRAM orders introduced in January 2026, and Micron's announcement on 3 December 2025 that it would close its Crucial consumer brand.
The numbers in the complaint
According to the order, the complaint says the three firms controlled over 91% of global DRAM revenue in the third quarter of 2025: SK hynix about 33.2%, Samsung 32.6% and Micron 25.7%. It cites reporting of DRAM price rises of about 50% in Q4 2025, 93% in Q1 2026 and 58% in Q2 2026, and alleges a 697% increase in conventional DRAM prices over 18 months.
Why the judge let it proceed
The companies argued the case was a rerun of an earlier one over the 2016-2018 DRAM price spike, which was dismissed and upheld on appeal in 2022. Judge Wise disagreed, finding the new complaint alleges different conduct and enough "plus factors", such as actions allegedly against each company's own self-interest, to make an agreement plausible.
At the hearing, the defendants quoted Judge Richard Posner's line that competitors in concentrated markets "watch each other like hawks". The judge replied in her order that the plaintiffs' allegations "go beyond hawks watching each other; their contentions are more akin to hawks flying in formation – an activity that hawks ordinarily do not do." She also noted it remains possible that each company acted independently.
What happens next
The order sets 7 December 2026 as the deadline for the companies to file their answers, and resets the initial case management conference to 12 January 2027. Antitrust class actions of this kind can take years to resolve. We haven't seen public comment from the three companies on the ruling.
What it means for UK buyers
Not much, immediately. This is a US case brought on behalf of US purchasers, and it won't change what you pay for a DDR5 kit this Black Friday. It is, though, a sign that the AI-driven memory squeeze behind high RAM prices is now being tested in court. For background on why memory has become so expensive, see why RAM and GPUs are expensive in 2026, and for current UK pricing, our DDR5 prices before Black Friday report.
If you need memory now, a 32GB DDR5-6000 kit remains the sweet spot for gaming. The court's order notes that module makers such as Kingston, Corsair and G.Skill buy conventional DRAM chips and sell finished modules to retailers and consumers, so the case covers the market behind the kits you buy. Our best DDR5 RAM guide has picks, and DDR5 CL30 vs CL36 explains whether the faster timings are worth paying for.
Our verdict
A US judge has ruled that the conspiracy claims against Samsung, SK hynix and Micron are plausible enough to go forward, describing the alleged behaviour as "hawks flying in formation". That is not a finding of guilt, the companies have yet to file their answers, and any outcome is likely years away. It won't lower UK RAM prices in the short term, but it puts the AI-era memory shortage under legal scrutiny. Forge PC hasn't reviewed the full complaint; this report is based on the court's order and published coverage.